OP’s brother, Jake, transitioned from female to male three years ago. OP is completely supportive of Jake’s transition and has asked him to be a part of her wedding party as a “bridesman”. However, Jake is reluctant to stand with the bridesmaids as he fears people will think he is still a girl. He believes that he should stand on OP’s fiancé’s side as a groomsman instead. OP disagrees with Jake’s reasoning and wants him to stand by her as originally planned.
It Wouldn’t Make Sense to Stand With Her Fiance
OP explains to Jake that it wouldn’t make sense for him to stand by her fiancé because they don’t have a close relationship, and her fiancé already has enough groomsmen.
And OP Wants Jake to Support Her
Moreover, Jake is OP’s brother, and she wants him to support her on her big day. Before Jake’s transition,
OP Doesn’t Understand Why Gender Would Change That
OP had always planned to include him in her wedding, so she doesn’t understand why his gender should change that.
OP Says He Can’t Be Part of the Wedding
Jake and OP argue back and forth for a while, with Jake accusing OP of still seeing him as a girl. OP insists that she sees him as a man and wants him to stand by her side. Eventually, OP tells Jake that he cannot be in the wedding party if he refuses to stand with her. Jake responds by calling OP names, leaving OP feeling awful.
He’s Still Invited as a Guest
Despite the argument, OP clarifies in an edit that Jake is still invited to the wedding as a guest. However, she has told him that he cannot be in the wedding party if he won’t stand with the bridesmaids.
Redditors Think That Op Is Overreacting
Most of the thread is willing to see that OP is acting very fairly and believes that her brother is overreacting:
“NTA, you aren’t telling him he has to restrict how he dresses, or making him dress like a gender he isn’t – this has no element of transphobia, he can be the bridesMAN he actually is.
It’s Weird That Genders Are Separated at Most Weddings
I always think it’s weird when people stand on the opposite persons side to keep genders separated. He’s a brides’ man, he’s your bro.
But if you’re from an area where that’s super weird I can kinda get where he’s coming from.”
OP Isn’t Insisting He Wears Anything in Particular
This Redditor makes some excellent points that a lot of the threads are in agreement with. Firstly, OP is not insisting her brother has to wear anything in particular. He is still free to wear whatever he likes.
He Just Has to Stand on OP’s Side
The key stipulation is that he will stand on OP’s side of the aisle. This is a very simple request, as he is her brother. This writer thinks it is very strange that this is what OP is taking offence to. There would be no reason to suggest that the brother is not a man just because he is on her brother’s side of the ceremony. This Redditor tries to somewhat understand OP’s brother’s side of the story but ultimately believes that he is in the wrong on this occasion.
The Brother Seems to Have an Ongoing Issue
It appears to be evident in a section of the thread that OP’s brother has some issues getting through:
“Agreed. Interestingly, I (male) was my best friend’s (female) man of honor at her wedding and the husband’s sister was his.
He Has a Lot of Processing to Do on Masculinity and Femininity
Tbh, it seems like the dude has a lot of processing to do on masculinity and femininity. He isn’t less of a dude for being on the bride’s side. But his reaction towards it shows there’s still a lot of processing (and maybe a bit of internalized patriarchy) running deep within him.”
The Brother Is Being Unreasonable
This Redditor suggests that the brother is being very much unreasonable in their response. Their argument for not wanting to stand on OP’s side is largely unfounded and nonsensical. In this case, it is most probable that the brother has some underlying issues that they need to resolve.
He’s Probably Over-Anxious About Being Humiliated
Moving from one gender to another is fraught with mental stress. It is likely that the brother is overly anxious about the possibility of being humiliated or called a woman for any reason, no matter how unlikely.
MORE FROM BECAUSE MOM SAYS:
THE HIDDEN DESIRES OF MEN: 10 THINGS MEN SECRETLY CRAVE IN A WIFE BUT DON’T HAVE THE COURAGE TO ADMIT
You may think that men only want two things from a wife, food and some fun in the bedroom. However, males are more complex than that. Here are ten things men want from their wife that will enhance the relationship.
STUCK IN THE 60S: 10 THINGS BABY BOOMERS REFUSE TO LET GO OF
Memories of the “good old days” keep us trapped in the past. Baby boomers love to retell tales of how it was “in my day.” At the same time, millennials will tell them to get with the times. Being stuck in a time warp from which they don’t want to snap out of, here are things that baby boomers still think are fantastic.
STUCK IN THE 60S: 10 THINGS BABY BOOMERS REFUSE TO LET GO OF
10 THINGS MEN DESIRE THAT WILL MAKE WOMEN RAISE THEIR EYEBROWS
You may think that, finally, you have your man figured out. How wrong you were. Here are 10 things men love that you may find surprising, according to an online forum.
10 THINGS MEN DESIRE THAT WILL MAKE WOMEN RAISE THEIR EYEBROWS
THE RED FLAGS ARE WAVING: 18 HOBBIES THAT WILL SCARE AWAY ANY POTENTIAL PARTNER
We wanted to know what hobbies are a big fat nope.
THE RED FLAGS ARE WAVING: 18 HOBBIES THAT WILL SCARE AWAY ANY POTENTIAL PARTNER
WAKE UP, LADIES! THE 10 BITTER TRUTHS MEN WISH WOMEN WOULD FINALLY ACKNOWLEDGE
Regarding men and women, it seems like we’re from different planets, though we are the same species. Women always come across as enigmatic, a mystery men must fathom. Yet, men can be just as challenging to understand. Here are ten things that men wish women knew about them. Hopefully, this helps females gain deeper insight into the world of men.
WAKE UP, LADIES! THE 10 BITTER TRUTHS MEN WISH WOMEN WOULD FINALLY ACKNOWLEDGE