Living next to a piano and violin teacher may seem harmonious, but frustration takes center stage when the music becomes a constant intrusion. The continual piano playing and violin screeching can drive even the most patient person to the brink. The struggle to maintain a sense of peace becomes real in a semi-detached house, where shared walls leave little room for escape. This article delves into the dilemma a homeowner faces, torn between the desire for harmony and the urge to preserve neighborly relations amidst the relentless tinkle-tinkle of the piano.
The Popular Online Forum User Presents Her Problem
“We have recently moved into a semi-detached house. On our attached side are a couple aged about 60 and a couple of lodgers. They are friendly people, I dropped a card in when we moved, and the woman has spoken to my husband a fair bit over the fence about gardening; not intrusive, very nice, and all good. However, she is a piano and violin teacher. On three weekdays (mostly after school), she teaches piano and violin, and it is like. She. Is. In. The. Room.”
Piano vs. Violin
The piano teacher’s lessons are a regular fixture, particularly on three weekdays after school. As her students struggle to master their instruments, the noise fills the air, making it feel like an everlasting concert in the home. But the violin lessons are a whole different level of cacophony, putting the household on edge.
As The Writer Puts It
“My kids are fairly noisy after school, so I kind of see it as a fair game.”
They tolerate the lessons, but the real challenge lies in enduring the teacher’s personal piano practices, even on weekends.
Frustration, Rage, and Escalating Thoughts
Living with constant piano noise can push anyone to their limits.
“I could kill her,” confesses the exasperated homeowner.
The intrusive music disrupts meals and becomes an annoying soundtrack to everyday life. The desperate desire to rip the piano out of the wall or take a machete to the musical instruments manifests the intense frustration built over time. As the thoughts escalate, the writer questions whether they can endure it any longer.
A Diplomatic Dilemma
The burning question for the homeowner is whether they should speak up about the issue or silently suffer through it. They acknowledge that the neighbor is friendly and has good intentions, making the dilemma more complex. Seeking a resolution becomes an ethical challenge, wanting to avoid alienating an otherwise amiable neighbor. The writer contemplates asking the piano teacher to move the instrument away from the shared wall, but the fear of revealing their discontent holds them back.
Opinions from the Community
As the writer seeks guidance from the community, opinions differ widely. Some argue that living in a semi-detached house means accepting a certain noise level, while others emphasize the need for a compromise. Suggestions include soundproofing the walls and asking the neighbor to use the mute pedal during personal practices. Some even share their experiences dealing with noisy neighbors, offering perspectives on both sides of the debate.
The Defense of the Piano Teacher
Amidst the debate, some community members defended the piano teacher’s right to practice her craft. They point out that she’s doing nothing wrong and simply enjoying her passion and livelihood in her home. They argue that the playing occurs during reasonable hours, making it a normal daytime noise, and one should consider that the teacher may feel similarly about the writer’s children making noise.
Sympathy from the Musicians
Fellow musicians show their empathy for both sides of the issue. Some reveal their experiences dealing with similar complaints and share their efforts to soundproof their homes. One pianist, who had faced a noise dispute, invested in a digital piano with headphones to practice without disturbing neighbors.
Another User, A Piano Teacher, Offers Up Her Advice
“You should be glad it’s classical music and not some pop-based dross. Sorry, I’m being facetious! As a piano teacher, I am conscious of running a business from home and the noise I cause. As such, we bought a house with a hallway separating the adjoining wall and then put the piano on the wall furthest away, as I understand that Mozart, on repeat, is not everyone’s cup of tea. I’ve always asked my neighbor to tell me if it’s annoying. I wouldn’t mind if I were her, you tell me. She may not realize.”
The Search for a Middle Ground
As the article progresses, the writer contemplates various compromises. They propose that the piano teacher move the instrument to another wall or limit playing hours when the writer puts their baby to bed. The hope is to find a solution that preserves harmony while acknowledging the piano teacher’s right to pursue her passion.
One User Suggested
“I play the piano – they’re very loud, and there’s no way I would dream of putting one against the adjoining wall. Listening to someone practice piano is ghastly – it’s not like hearing a performance. You break up the music, repeat segments endlessly, or go through scales and arpeggios. You have my sympathy. I moved to digital precisely so I could practice without alienating neighbors.”
While Another Said
“Try to find a compromise. She’s running a business from home, so it’s in her interests to agree with you as residents aren’t obliged to put up with constant noise arising from the business. There have been cases where a local authority has not been found favoring music teachers. I do feel sorry for them, but like other music bands, it may be that if they’re not in a detached property, they’ll have to hire a music room with a piano for the day and host lessons there.”
Finding a Resolution
Living with constant piano noise presents a genuine challenge for those in shared housing situations. The delicate balance between respecting a neighbor’s livelihood and maintaining personal peace of mind can create a dilemma that seems impossible to resolve. The community’s opinions reveal the situation’s complexity, with perspectives ranging from complete understanding to firm complaints. Finding common ground and exploring soundproofing options might be the key to harmonious coexistence. Until then, the piano will continue to tinkle, and the debate will play on.
“Soundproofing materials and techniques have advanced in recent years, and since you want to keep things sweet with your neighbors, you could ask an expert to advise on what’s feasible and how much difference it could make from your side. Further options would be to ask the neighbors to consider soundproofing their side or moving house. Is that why the previous occupants moved, do you think?”
He Sold the Family Home for Three Times What He Paid for It, but Now His Siblings Are Demanding a Share of the Profit
A man bought his two siblings out of their share of the family home when their mother passed away. Now he’s sold the house for three times the amount he paid for it, and his siblings are demanding a cut.
This Groom Invited His Ex-Girlfriend To His Wedding, But When She Showed Up In Suspenders He Had His Regrets!
Recently, a couple decided to have a micro wedding with just their immediate family, around ten people. They chose a venue known for holding significant events, but they hired a smaller room there.
This Groom Invited His Ex-Girlfriend To His Wedding, But When She Showed Up In Suspenders He Had His Regrets!
He Was Blinded by Love, Until He Learned About His Romanian Wife’s True Motives
In a tale fraught with deception and vengeance, a man recently divulged his experience of unmasking his Romanian wife’s infidelity and orchestrating a chain of events that ultimately led to the revocation of her Greencard, laying bare her hidden agenda.
He Was Blinded by Love, Until He Learned About His Romanian Wife’s True Motives